Union-Tribune Editorial: Air board still scandalous!
|Air board still scandalous
Contrary evidence on diesel rules seems to be ignored
By Union-Tribune Editorial Board,
Saturday, July 17, 2010 at 12:02 a.m.
In December 2008, this editorial page reported that Hien Tran – the
lead California Air Resources Board scientist on a study used to
justify sweeping, costly new rules on diesel emissions – had lied about
his academic credentials. The scandal seemed to unfold in slow motion.
Finally, 10 months later, two members of the air board – Fresno
cardiologist John Telles and San Diego County Supervisor Ron Roberts –
denounced the regulatory agency for not disclosing Tran’s dishonesty
before the vote to adopt diesel rules based on his work. This helped
prompt the suspension of the rules.
Now, 10 more months have passed, and something extremely curious is unfolding.
to promises made by air board Chairwoman Mary Nichols, the accuracy of
Tran’s central premise – that PM2.5 (tiny soot particles from exhaust,
smoke and dust) causes thousands of premature deaths each year in
California – has been found wanting. In February, a CARB-commissioned
outside study was released that found no evidence for his claim. This
corroborated independent scientists who said Tran’s theory was flawed
because it was based on studies from Eastern states, where sulfates are
common and may interact with PM2.5 to harmful effect.
Yet this finding doesn’t seem to have had any effect on regulators, who
have informally made clear to industry groups that they still want to
impose Tran’s rules even though they will bankrupt hundreds of small
businesses that can’t afford expensive new engines or engine retrofits.
isn’t right. Roberts’ spokesman said Friday that the supervisor plans
to raise questions at a board meeting next week about the air board
staff’s reaction to the contrary evidence. In disturbing ways, the
reaction parallels the staff’s reaction to confirmation of Tran’s
deceit and its decision to pursue a cover-up. It may be time for Telles
and Roberts to give another lecture to Nichols on honesty and
...and a weak responce from James Goldstene, the Executive Director of CARB
Note: James Goldstene has no science background--only a degree in "Government". His bio is here.
|Letters: California Air Resources Board responds
Saturday, July 24, 2010 at 12:02 a.m.
The July 17th Union-Tribune editorial (“Air board still scandalous”)
repeats discredited claims that the health science related to fine
particles emitted from diesel-fueled engines and other sources is too
uncertain to support the California Air Resources Board’s tough
To the contrary: Last month, the U.S Environmental Protection Agency
issued a report approved by the federal Clean Air Act Scientific
Advisory Committee concluding that there is a causal relationship
between exposure to these fine particles (known as PM2.5) and premature
death, and includes estimates of premature deaths linked to PM2.5 in
cities throughout the country, including Los Angeles and Fresno. The
report also provides a new factor for estimating premature deaths
associated with PM2.5 that the ARB will rely on going forward.
The U.S. EPA and its Clean Air Act Scientific Advisory Committee
considered evidence from multiple peer-reviewed studies, including
studies pointing to plausible biological mechanisms for cardiovascular
deaths associated with PM2.5. A 2009 peer-reviewed American Cancer
Society study, which followed nearly half a million people in 116
cities, found premature death linked to PM2.5 – including in Los
Angeles. While the relative proportion of PM2.5 constituents can vary,
California cities have a mix of pollutants quite similar to that found
in other cities.
Diesel defenders cite a handful of California-specific studies that
failed to find PM2.5 particles as a health hazard in California but
ignore the weight of evidence from multiple studies. While the
ARB-commissioned study referenced in the editorial did not produce
results identical to the American Cancer Society study, preliminary
findings show a correlation between death from heart disease and
exposure to PM2.5. Other California studies are consistent with the
national studies. These issues were expressly discussed and debated in
a public symposium conducted by CARB in February of this year.
Peer-reviewed studies have always been the source of health findings
cited in CARB reports. It’s time to recognize that CARB has a legal
obligation to reduce PM 2.5 emissions to meet federal air quality
standards by the 2014 deadline, and that the science and the health
basis for that mandate is as strong as ever.
JAMES N. GOLDSTENE
Executive Officer California Air Resources Board
You can write to the Union-Tribubne . . . and here's how
|To encourage community
dialogue on important public matters, The San Diego Union-Tribune
welcomes letters to the editor. Space is limited, so we offer these
tips and policy guidelines:
Please be aware that lengthy letters reduce chances for publication. Our suggested maximum length is 200 words.
To allow as many letter writers as possible to be published, it is the
policy of the newspaper to publish no more than one letter from the
same author within 30 days.
Letters should be exclusive to the Union-Tribune. “Open letters” and
submissions sent originally to individuals, agencies or other media
outlets will not be considered for publication.
We prefer letters that reference items published in the Union-Tribune within the past month.
Letters may be edited for space, grammar, clarity or other reasons.
It is our policy to publish letters supporting or opposing a particular
issue in a ratio reflecting the number received on each side.
All letters considered for publication will be verified for
authenticity. Letters must include a full name, address, daytime phone
number and, if faxed or mailed, be signed. E-mail submissions are
preferred and can be sent to email@example.com.
Letters can be mailed to Letters Editor, The San Diego Union-Tribune,
P.O. Box 120191, San Diego, CA 92112-0191, or faxed to (619) 260-5081.
Letters submitted may be used in print or in digital form in any
publication or service authorized by the Union-Tribune Publishing Co.